By using this site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Accept
BGTNBGTNBGTN
  • Home
  • TV Channels
    • 1 – Global TV
    • 2 – Mining TV
    • 3 – Sports TV
  • BRICS
    • B – Brasil
    • R – Россия (Rossiya)
    • I – भारत (Bhārat)
    • C – 中国 (Zhōngguó)
    • S – South Africa
    • BRICS Plus
      • A – Argentina
      • E – مصر (Misr)
      • E – ኢትዮጵያ (Ityop’iya)
      • I – ایران (Irān)
      • S – السعودية (Al-Su’udiyya)
      • U – الإمارات العربية المتحدة
    • BRICS Partner States
      • A – الجزائر
      • B – Bolivia
      • B – Беларусь
      • C – Cuba
      • K – Қазақстан
      • I – Indonesia
      • M – Malaysia
      • N – Nigeria
      • T – ประเทศไทย
      • T – Türkiye
      • U – Uganda
      • U – Oʻzbekiston
      • V – Việt Nam
  • International
  • Sports
  • Features
    • Hearts and Plates
    • Saudi Vision 2030
    • Business and Finance
    • Technology and Trends
    • Arts and Culture
    • Health and Lifestyle
    • Food and Agriculture
    • Travel and Exploration
    • BGTN Cares
  • Weather
Reading: Dreams of a ‘broken up’ Russia might turn into a nightmare for the West – and an opportunity for China
Share
Font ResizerAa
Font ResizerAa
BGTNBGTN
  • Brasil
  • Россия (Rossiya)
  • भारत (Bhārat)
  • 中国 (Zhōngguó)
  • South Africa
  • Argentina
  • مصر (Misr)
  • ኢትዮጵያ (Ityop’iya)
  • ایران (Irān)
  • السعودية (Al-Su’udiyya)
  • الإمارات العربية المتحدة
  • الجزائر
  • Bolivia
  • Беларусь
  • Cuba
  • Қазақстан
  • Indonesia
  • Malaysia
  • Nigeria
  • ประเทศไทย
  • Türkiye
  • Uganda
  • Oʻzbekiston
  • Việt Nam
  • Home
  • TV Channels
    • 1 – Global TV
    • 2 – Mining TV
    • 3 – Sports TV
  • BRICS
    • B – Brasil
    • R – Россия (Rossiya)
    • I – भारत (Bhārat)
    • C – 中国 (Zhōngguó)
    • S – South Africa
    • BRICS Plus
    • BRICS Partner States
  • International
  • Sports
  • Features
    • Hearts and Plates
    • Saudi Vision 2030
    • Business and Finance
    • Technology and Trends
    • Arts and Culture
    • Health and Lifestyle
    • Food and Agriculture
    • Travel and Exploration
    • BGTN Cares
  • Weather
Follow US
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
© 2024 BRICS Global Television Network. Newshound Media. All Rights Reserved.
BGTN > International > Dreams of a ‘broken up’ Russia might turn into a nightmare for the West – and an opportunity for China
International

Dreams of a ‘broken up’ Russia might turn into a nightmare for the West – and an opportunity for China

The Conversation
Last updated: November 20, 2023 7:31 am
By The Conversation
11 Min Read
Share
Globe Asia
Photo: iStock.
SHARE

Susan Smith-Peter, City University of New York

Contents
Rise of the ‘breakup boosters’Problems of geographyRussia’s Far East, China’s backyard

Do names on a map matter? When they are in border territories, the answer is probably “yes.”

Earlier in 2023, China’s Ministry of Natural Resources ordered that new maps must use the former Chinese names of its lost territories in what is now Russia’s Far East.

Vladivostok, home to Russia’s Pacific fleet headquarters, became Haishenwai; Sakhalin Island became Kuyedao.

Then in late August, the ministry released a map that showed the disputed Russian territory of Bolshoi Ussuriysky Island within China’s borders.

These map moves come amid growing chatter and even calls in Western foreign policy circles for the disintegration of the Russian Federation into a multitude of smaller states.

The thinking is, being split into smaller states would blunt Russia’s challenge to the West and its ability to carry on a war in Ukraine.

As a scholar of Russian regional identity and history, I believe the prospect of a broken-up Russia is unlikely, to say the least.

But talk of Russia’s disintegration and the change in map names taps into themes worth exploring: Is there much appetite for independence in the far regions of the Russian state?

And if there were to be breakaway regions in the Far East, would that be to the benefit of the West – or to China?

ALSO READ: Ukraine and Russia traded barbs in the UN’s top court over the invasion’s legality. What could happen next in the case?

Rise of the ‘breakup boosters’

Those calling for, or predicting, the disintegration of the Russian Federation have grown in numbers since the start of the Ukraine war. In the book “Failed State: A guide to Russia’s Rupture,” political scientist Janusz Bugajski argues that the territories of the Russian Federation will in time declare independence – like during the fall of the Soviet Union in 1991.

This, he and others argue, would be good for everyone outside Russia. A rump Russian state would have “reduced capabilities to attack neighbors,” Bugajski argues.

The Washington Post’s David Ignatius has a gloomier view of Russian disintegration, writing in August that it would provide “a devil’s playground” that could pose a danger to the West.

Either way, a growing number of analysts are of a mind that, in the words of Russia scholar Alexander J. Motyl, it is “time to start taking the potential disintegration of Russia seriously.”

Having worked on the history of Russian regionalism for two decades, I see serious obstacles to territories declaring independence.

It is certainly true that centralized authority has been to the detriment – both economically and culturally – to some of the Russian Federation’s 83 regions.

But there is a lack of mass public support for autonomy – that is, the ability to decide local and regional matters within a larger state – let alone full-blown independence.

Not all regions in Russia are the same. In some, such as Tatarstan and Dagestan, autonomy has a genuine mass appeal.

But most Russian regions that favor greater autonomy are in locations that would make it difficult for them to declare independence outright because they would still be surrounded by the Russian Federation.

Those in a locations more suited to independence – say, those that have borders with neighboring countries – often face other difficulties, such as being close to China.

In Russia’s Far East, there is concern among would-be breakaways that independence could lead to the possibility of an interventionist China either taking over or at least exerting its influence.

Problems of geography

“Breakup boosters” – the term I use to describe those advocating for Russia’s disintegration – assume that regions in the Russian Federation all have aspirations for independence.

But an analysis of Russian regions by Adam Lenton of Wake Forest University found a highly variable level of support for autonomy across Russian regions.

The data shows that in many of the regions that have exiled independence leaders and are talked about of being potential breakaways, the public doesn’t support that goal.

The data shows support for autonomy rather than independence. Autonomy would make the Russian Federation a real federation.

The region with by far the most support for autonomy is Tatarstan, a subnational republic led by Turkic-speaking Tatar people 447 miles south of Moscow.

But arguing that this should lead to independence makes little sense – it would be completely surrounded by a hostile Russian Federation. An independent foreign and defense policy in such circumstances would be almost impossible.

Some Tatars have themselves argued against independence on this ground.

The regions of the North Caucasus have some of the highest scores, plus a foreign border with Georgia making it potentially a better candidate for independence. But the region has a bitter experience with attempts to break away. Chechnya’s attempt at independence failed after a long and bloody war.

In Siberia, the region of Tuva has high levels of support for autonomy. But it is in China’s backyard – and this would make it geographically vulnerable.

ALSO READ: Russia dismisses new U.S. sanctions: ‘You will never defeat Moscow’

Russia’s Far East, China’s backyard

Russia’s Far East includes the Amur region along the border with China and Vladivostok. These were taken from China by Russia during the mid-19th century, when Russian general Nikolai Murav’ev-Amurskii used Russia’s greater firepower and more modern army to defeat China.

But the status of territories in the region remained contentious. In 1969, China and the Soviet Union fought a seven-month undeclared war over border issues.

After 1991, China and Russia went through several rounds of talks and treaties to ensure that the border between them was ratified by both parties, with the last treaty taking place in 2004. Even so, not all groups within China accept the results.

Textbooks in China still mention the loss of 1.5 million square kilometers to Russia and note that Mao Zedong, the founder of the People’s Republic of China, said he would “present the bill,” meaning that Russia would have to pay what Mao perceived as the theft of territory.

The fear among some Russians – and those in the West – is that China could turn Russia’s Far East into its satellite, using it as a source of raw materials such as diamonds and gold, as well as oil and gas. And with economic hegemony comes political influence.

China faces challenges that make increasing its influence in Russia’s Far East particularly attractive now, including what experts see as a structural economic crisis and a rural education gap. Territorial expansion could provide economic growth while serving as a distraction from domestic issues.

ALSO READ: BRICS Currency: Russian economist highlights benefits for international trade

But the breakup of the Russian Federation could also pose a security threat to China. The experience of Xinjiang serves as a warning. The region, which has been the focus of China’s persecution of the Muslim Uyghur people, had twice been a breakaway region under the protection of former Soviet leader Josef Stalin.

Furthermore, the Chinese Communist Party will be fearful that any unrest in areas of the Russian Federation that are close to Xinjiang might spill over.

Given all this, the argument from breakup boosters that no one, other than President Vladimir Putin, would lose if the Russian Federation disintegrated is, I believe, simply not sustainable.

And rather than hastening the disintegration of the Russian Federation, polls suggest that the war in Ukraine is having a unifying effect. Many Russians who were originally against the war have become reluctant supporters of it – in part because of propaganda that has emphasized the threat from the West to Russia’s territorial integrity. Since 2021, Russia’s military doctrine has highlighted this threat, stating that one of the main issues facing the nation was groups “aimed at violating the unity and territorial integrity of the Russian Federation.”

The calls in the West for the breakup of the Russian Federation might suggest to the Russian public that Putin’s territorial fears could become a reality. Moreover, dreams of a broken Russian Federation might distract those in the West from the very real problem of helping Ukraine protect its own territorial integrity.

Susan Smith-Peter, Professor of Russian History, City University of New York

*This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

NOW READ: Israel-Hamas war puts China’s strategy of ‘balanced diplomacy’ in the Middle East at risk

BRICS Summit: New opportunities for coffee trade between Brazil and South Africa
Weekly News Roundup | 1st June 2024
Houthi rebel Red Sea attacks and the threat of escalation and supply chain chaos are a major headache – and not just for the West
Weekly News Roundup | 20th July 2024
BRICS Nations engage in intensive foreign policy dialogue on peace diplomacy in Africa
Share This Article
Facebook Flipboard Pinterest Whatsapp Whatsapp LinkedIn Tumblr Reddit VKontakte Telegram Threads Email Copy Link Print
What do you think?
Love0
Sad0
Happy0
Surprise0
Shy0
Joy0
Cry0
Embarrass0
Sleepy0
Angry0
Dead0
Wink0
Previous Article Argentina Elections Javier Milei, Liberty Advances coalition presidential candidate, right, greets supporters during his closing campaign rally in Cordoba, Argentina, Thursday, Nov. 16, 2023. Milei will face Economy Minister Sergio Massa, the ruling party's candidate, in a runoff election on Nov. 19 Economic crisis and unpredictable electoral phenomenon make this election the most important in the last 40 years in Argentina
Next Article Rescuers search for people trapped under a wall that collapsed on several vehicles after heavy rains on 27 de Febrero Avenue in Santo Domingo on November 18, 2023. WATCH: At least 21 dead in torrential Dominican Republic rains
Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Stay Connected

FacebookLike
XFollow
PinterestPin
InstagramFollow
YoutubeSubscribe
TiktokFollow
LinkedInFollow
TumblrFollow
ThreadsFollow
BlueskyFollow
RSS FeedFollow
- Advertisement -
Ad imageAd image

Latest News

Jenna Clifford (1959–2025): South Africa’s Queen of Bespoke Jewellery
BRICS South Africa
Rutube: A Thriving Platform for Russian Content & Creator Monetisation
BRICS Россия (Rossiya)
New Development Bank and SANRAL Sign ZAR7 Billion Deal to Upgrade South Africa road infrastructure upgrade
BRICS South Africa
Unlocking Africa’s potential through bold collaboration and stronger investability
BRICS South Africa

You Might Also Like

International

A British man runs the length of Africa

April 8, 2024
Gaza damage
International

UPDATE: Israel bombards Gaza, Lebanon as Netanyahu convenes war cabinet

October 23, 2023
International

BGTN – Weekly Roundup stories making headlines in BRICS countries around the World

March 27, 2024
Sadhguru at COP28
International

WATCH: Soil Guru, Here’s why India’s famous mystic is ringing the alarm about soil deficiency at COP28

December 6, 2023

Our Partners

Ad imageAd image

Learn About BRICS

  • B – Brasil
  • R – Россия (Rossiya)
  • I – भारत (Bhārat)
  • C – 中国 (Zhōngguó)
  • S – South Africa
  • Saudi Vision 2030

Our World

  • A message from the Founder & CEO
  • Support Centre
  • Careers

Google Translate

BGTNBGTN
Follow US
© 2025 BRICS Global Television Network (Pty) Ltd. All Rights Reserved. Independent Media Platform. Unauthorized ownership claims or affiliations are unlawful.
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Username or Email Address
Password

Lost your password?