Guterres’ Arrival in Kazan
United Nations (UN) Secretary-General António Guterres is currently in Kazan, Russia, attending the BRICS summit hosted by President Vladimir Putin. His decision to participate has drawn strong criticism from Ukraine and its allies, particularly in light of the ongoing conflict that began with Russia’s full-scale invasion in 2022.
Reactions from Ukraine and Allies
Guterres’ involvement in the summit, which includes countries like China and Iran, has sparked backlash. Ukraine’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs stated on X (formerly Twitter) that his choice “does not advance the cause of peace” and “damages the UN’s reputation.” They also highlighted that Guterres had declined an invitation to a peace summit in Switzerland earlier this year.
Lithuanian Foreign Minister Gabrielius Landsbergis labeled Guterres’ participation as “unacceptable,” reflecting widespread concern among Ukraine’s allies about engaging with Russia at this level.
Guterres’ Possible Goals
Stewart Patrick, a senior fellow at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, speculates that Guterres may aim to facilitate a peace deal. He suggests that Guterres might share concerns with BRICS countries regarding the inclusion of diverse voices in international institutions. However, Patrick cautions that this approach may not align well with Western nations, who might perceive it as tacit support for Putin’s policies.
Guterres’ attendance at the BRICS summit underscores the complex nature of international diplomacy amid the ongoing conflict in Ukraine. As discussions progress, the impact of this summit on global peace efforts remains uncertain.
Russia’s Expanded BRICS Meeting Sparks Concern Across Europe
The summit also includes notable leaders such as China’s Xi Jinping, India’s Narendra Modi, and Turkey’s Recep Tayyip Erdoğan. Their participation has raised alarms among policymakers in the European Union (EU).
Economic Implications for Europe
Beyond geopolitical worries, the economic power of a united BRICS bloc is concerning many in Europe. Enrico Letta, a former Prime Minister of Italy, has emphasized the importance of strengthening economic ties within Europe. He warns that enhancing the EU’s single market is crucial for determining whether Europe will become a “colony of the US or of China” in the future.
The expanded BRICS meeting signifies a pivotal moment in global economic dynamics. As Europe contemplates its response, the need for strategic unity and proactive measures has never been clearer.
Details of the Expanded BRICS Summit
Originally comprised of Brazil, Russia, India, China, and South Africa, the BRICS summit has expanded this year to include Iran, Egypt, Ethiopia, Saudi Arabia, and the United Arab Emirates. The summit, taking place over several days in Kazan, will address various global challenges. Together, these nations account for over 37% of the global GDP, positioning BRICS as a potential rival to the G7 and NATO.
Internal Tensions Within BRICS
Among the agenda items is the addition of new members, which could exacerbate existing tensions within BRICS. Notably, China and India have regional rivalries, while new entrants like Saudi Arabia and Iran have historically been adversaries.
Controversial Attendees at the Meeting
One of the most notable participants is Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan. Turkey, which has the second-largest army in NATO and has historically aligned with the West, reflects a recent shift in its foreign policy due to frustration over being denied EU membership.
