A live debate among candidates for the São Paulo mayoral election in Brasil took a dramatic turn when one of the contenders, José Luiz Datena, struck his opponent Pablo Marçal with a chair. The incident left the audience and other participants in shock, turning what was meant to be a serious political discussion into a scene of chaos.
Sunday’s debate, featuring six candidates vying for the position of mayor in Brasil’s largest city, was already tense when things escalated quickly between Datena and Marçal. José Luiz Datena, a well-known TV presenter, lost his temper after Marçal, a far-right influencer, challenged his threats from a previous debate. Marçal taunted Datena, suggesting he wasn’t “man enough” to follow through with his earlier threat to hit him. This jab struck a nerve, and Datena responded by grabbing a chair and hitting Marçal on the shoulder.
Conflict
The conflict between the two didn’t come out of nowhere. In a prior debate, Marçal had brought up an old sexual harassment allegation made against Datena in 2019. Though the accuser later withdrew her complaint, she claimed she had been pressured into staying silent. Marçal’s mention of this controversy struck a chord with Datena, fuelling their increasingly bitter exchanges over the campaign period.
The moment Datena swung the chair, the debate came to a halt. Debate organizers swiftly expelled Datena from the stage, and Marçal, injured by the blow, left to seek medical treatment. His spokesperson later revealed that Marçal had suffered a bruised rib from the attack.
Despite the dramatic interruption, the remaining candidates decided to continue the debate. However, it was clear that the mood had shifted. What was meant to be a platform for discussing São Paulo’s future had turned into a national headline for all the wrong reasons.
José Luiz Datena’s campaign had been struggling before the incident. According to recent polls, he was sitting in fifth place ahead of the October 6th election, with around 6% of voter support. In contrast, Marçal, despite being new to politics, had gained traction thanks to his fiery debate performances, positioning him in third place behind conservative incumbent Ricardo Nunes and leftist rival Guilherme Boulos. Both Nunes and Boulos are neck-and-neck, each holding about 25% of voter intentions, according to a Datafolha poll.
The altercation between Datena and Marçal has now become the biggest talking point of the election so far, sparking a wave of reactions across Brasil. Political analysts have already begun debating whether the incident will hurt or help Datena’s chances in the election.
While it might seem like an outburst like Datena’s would destroy any hopes of gaining more support, some experts believe the opposite could happen. André Cesar, a political consultant at Hold Assessoria Legislativa, suggests that Datena’s dramatic action might draw more attention to his campaign.
“Most voters had no idea Datena was even running for mayor. Now, everyone is talking about him,” Cesar said. “It was good theater, designed to help a campaign that was lagging.” In other words, Datena’s impulsive behavior, while inappropriate, may have done exactly what his campaign needed—made him relevant in an election where he was struggling to gain traction.
A wave of new polls has been commissioned to assess how voters in São Paulo, a city of 11.5 million people, are reacting to the incident. While political consultancy Eurasia doesn’t expect the chair-throwing debacle to change the overall dynamics of the race significantly, it has certainly created a buzz around Datena.
Influencer
Pablo Marçal, the recipient of Datena’s rage, has been making a name for himself as a far-right influencer with a provocative style. His rise in the polls has been fueled by viral moments like these, where his aggressive debate tactics have brought him widespread attention. By pushing Datena’s buttons and bringing up sensitive issues from his past, Marçal was likely aiming to provoke a reaction—though he probably didn’t expect it to go quite this far.
Despite the physical altercation, Marçal’s team seems confident that the incident won’t damage his campaign. In fact, his spokesperson pointed out that Marçal has already positioned himself as a disruptor, someone who’s unafraid to confront more established politicians and stir the pot. This latest development could further cement that image in the eyes of his supporters.
While Datena and Marçal grabbed the headlines, incumbent mayor Ricardo Nunes and leftist candidate Guilherme Boulos have been steadily battling it out at the top of the polls. Both candidates are running on very different platforms, but they share a common goal: to keep the focus of the campaign on substantive issues rather than personal conflicts.
Nunes, the conservative current mayor, has been campaigning on his track record in office, while Boulos, a seasoned leftist activist, is pushing for more progressive policies in the city. The two are in a tight race, each holding about a quarter of voter support.
Outcome
It remains to be seen whether the drama surrounding Datena and Marçal will shift the focus of the election or simply provide a temporary distraction. Both Nunes and Boulos are likely hoping the voters will continue to focus on their platforms rather than the spectacle that unfolded during the debate.
With the election fast approaching, it’s clear that this incident will be a defining moment for Datena and Marçal’s campaigns. For Datena, the challenge will be turning this attention into actual voter support. While the spectacle may have increased his visibility, it’s not clear whether it will translate into votes.
Marçal, on the other hand, will likely continue to play up his role as the provocateur. Whether this strategy will help him move further up the polls remains to be seen, but he has certainly solidified his reputation as someone willing to go toe-to-toe with his opponents—sometimes literally.
Election conclusion.
As for São Paulo voters, the chair-throwing incident may have added a layer of unpredictability to the race. With the October 6th election around the corner, the city will soon decide whether it wants its next mayor to be someone who plays by the rules—or someone who’s not afraid to break them.
ALSO READ: Brazilian and Russian yachtsmen plan joint expedition along Arctic’s Northern Sea route
