On 13 September 2024, President Cyril Ramaphosa signed the Basic Education Laws Amendment (BELA) Act into law, marking a significant yet contentious milestone in South Africa’s educational landscape. The BELA Act aims to strengthen governance within the education sector, but it has sparked considerable resistance from various organizations and political entities.
Reasons for resistance
The BELA Act has faced opposition from multiple fronts, including educational organizations, political parties, and civil society groups. The primary concerns revolve around:
Language policy: One of the most contentious aspects of the BELA Act is its impact on language policy in schools. The Act grants the government greater control over the language of instruction, which many fear could marginalize local languages like Afrikaans. Critics argue that this move undermines linguistic diversity and the cultural heritage of minority communities.
School governance: The Act also introduces changes to school governance, including the composition and powers of school governing bodies (SGBs). Opponents claim that these changes centralize power in the hands of the government, reducing the autonomy of schools and communities to make decisions that best suit their needs.
Implementation concerns: There are significant concerns about the practical implementation of the BELA Act. Critics argue that the government lacks the capacity and resources to effectively enforce the new regulations, potentially leading to confusion and disruption in schools.
Impact on schooling and language policy
The BELA Act’s language policy provisions have generated the most heated debate. By allowing the government to dictate the language of instruction, the Act could significantly impact the use of local languages in schools. Afrikaans, in particular, stands to be affected. Historically, Afrikaans has been a medium of instruction in many schools, and its speakers fear that the new law could lead to its gradual phasing out in favor of English or other languages.
This shift could have broader implications for educational outcomes and social cohesion. Research has shown that children learn best in their mother tongue, especially in the early years of schooling. The marginalization of Afrikaans and other local languages could therefore negatively impact students’ academic performance and engagement.
Political implications and coalition dynamics
The signing of the BELA Act has also stirred political tensions within the Government of National Unity and the coalition government, particularly between the African National Congress (ANC) and the Democratic Alliance (DA). The DA has been a vocal critic of the Act, arguing that it infringes on the rights of schools and communities. This disagreement has strained the relationship between the two parties, highlighting the challenges of maintaining a cohesive coalition government.
The ANC, on the other hand, has defended the Act as a necessary step to modernize and improve the education system. However, the internal divisions and public backlash could weaken the party’s position and influence within the coalition, potentially leading to further political instability.
Future prospects and implementation
Looking ahead, the successful implementation of the BELA Act will be crucial in determining its long-term impact. The government will need to address the concerns raised by critics, particularly regarding language policy and school governance. Effective communication and collaboration with stakeholders, including educators, parents, and community leaders, will be essential to ensure a smooth transition and minimize disruption in schools.
Moreover, continuous monitoring and evaluation will be necessary to assess the Act’s impact on educational outcomes and social cohesion. The government may need to make adjustments and provide additional support to schools to address any challenges that arise during implementation.
The signing of the BELA Act represents a significant but contentious development in South Africa’s education sector. While it aims to strengthen governance and improve educational outcomes, the resistance it has generated highlights the complexities and challenges of implementing such sweeping reforms. The future of the Act will depend on the government’s ability to address the concerns of stakeholders and ensure that the changes benefit all students, regardless of their linguistic or cultural background.
ALSO READ: South Africa proposes major changes to carbon tax laws to boost renewable energy investments
