By using this site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Accept
BGTNBGTNBGTN
  • Home
  • TV Channels
    • 1 – Global TV
    • 2 – Mining TV
    • 3 – Sports TV
  • BRICS
    • B – Brasil
    • R – Россия (Rossiya)
    • I – भारत (Bhārat)
    • C – 中国 (Zhōngguó)
    • S – South Africa
    • BRICS Plus
      • A – Argentina
      • E – مصر (Misr)
      • E – ኢትዮጵያ (Ityop’iya)
      • I – ایران (Irān)
      • S – السعودية (Al-Su’udiyya)
      • U – الإمارات العربية المتحدة
    • BRICS Partner States
      • A – الجزائر
      • B – Bolivia
      • B – Беларусь
      • C – Cuba
      • K – Қазақстан
      • I – Indonesia
      • M – Malaysia
      • N – Nigeria
      • T – ประเทศไทย
      • T – Türkiye
      • U – Uganda
      • U – Oʻzbekiston
      • V – Việt Nam
  • International
  • Sports
  • Features
    • Hearts and Plates
    • Saudi Vision 2030
    • Business and Finance
    • Technology and Trends
    • Arts and Culture
    • Health and Lifestyle
    • Food and Agriculture
    • Travel and Exploration
    • BGTN Cares
  • Weather
Reading: Yes, Israel’s occupation of Palestinian lands has to end – but massacres of civilians won’t bring this end any closer
Share
Font ResizerAa
Font ResizerAa
BGTNBGTN
  • Brasil
  • Россия (Rossiya)
  • भारत (Bhārat)
  • 中国 (Zhōngguó)
  • South Africa
  • Argentina
  • مصر (Misr)
  • ኢትዮጵያ (Ityop’iya)
  • ایران (Irān)
  • السعودية (Al-Su’udiyya)
  • الإمارات العربية المتحدة
  • الجزائر
  • Bolivia
  • Беларусь
  • Cuba
  • Қазақстан
  • Indonesia
  • Malaysia
  • Nigeria
  • ประเทศไทย
  • Türkiye
  • Uganda
  • Oʻzbekiston
  • Việt Nam
  • Home
  • TV Channels
    • 1 – Global TV
    • 2 – Mining TV
    • 3 – Sports TV
  • BRICS
    • B – Brasil
    • R – Россия (Rossiya)
    • I – भारत (Bhārat)
    • C – 中国 (Zhōngguó)
    • S – South Africa
    • BRICS Plus
    • BRICS Partner States
  • International
  • Sports
  • Features
    • Hearts and Plates
    • Saudi Vision 2030
    • Business and Finance
    • Technology and Trends
    • Arts and Culture
    • Health and Lifestyle
    • Food and Agriculture
    • Travel and Exploration
    • BGTN Cares
  • Weather
Follow US
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
© 2024 BRICS Global Television Network. Newshound Media. All Rights Reserved.
BGTN > International > Yes, Israel’s occupation of Palestinian lands has to end – but massacres of civilians won’t bring this end any closer
International

Yes, Israel’s occupation of Palestinian lands has to end – but massacres of civilians won’t bring this end any closer

The Conversation
Last updated: October 20, 2023 6:59 am
By The Conversation
10 Min Read
Share
3D map of Israel with topographic relief, borders. stock photo
3D map of Israel with topographic relief, borders. Photo: iStock.
SHARE

Eyal Mayroz, University of Sydney

Contents
Palestinian despairLittle empathy across fencesSaying ‘no’ to any violence against civiliansEnding the occupation

Israel: Notwithstanding a brief period of hope in the mid-1990s, successive Israeli governments have long held that the country’s security must inevitably rely on military might. But what may have worked in other places has not proven sustainable for the complex realities of the Israel-Palestine situation.

In the century-long feud between the two sides over land, there’s been little respite from violence. Competing territorial claims continue to fuel duelling narratives of victimisation. These foment anger, animosity, fear and mistrust. Colossal leadership errors on both sides during historical junctures have led to missed opportunities to resolve a conflict that becomes more intractable by the year.

On the Jewish Israeli side, deep-rooted existential fears, following millennia of persecution, pogroms and the trauma of the Holocaust, were later exacerbated by a number of mostly defensive wars fought against neighbouring Arab states.

From the 1960s, Israel’s desire for security was further challenged by continual terrorist attacks targeting its civilians. These experiences resulted in strong society-wide yearnings – to a level unfathomable by outsiders – for military supremacy as a means to ensure the country’s survival.

On the Palestinian side, experiences of dispossession, injustice, deprivation, daily humiliation, endless violations of rights and a sense of abandonment by the world – including by Arab states – have caused immeasurable despair.

Added to the tensions since the 1980s have been the steadily increasing influences of religious and radical nationalist ideologies on both sides of the fence. These developments have all but stymied hopes for a negotiated end to the conflict in the foreseeable future.

ALSO READ: Biden’s trip to Israel ties him and the US to any Gaza offensive

Palestinian despair

After decades of oppression, the sense of hopelessness among Palestinians has reached a peak, aggravated by the realities on the ground:

  • a continued illegal expansion of Jewish settlements in the West Bank and fears of wholesale annexation of Palestinian lands
  • worsening Jewish settler violence, aided at times, or not prevented by, Israel’s security forces
  • a suffocating 16-year blockade of Gaza following Israel’s 2005 withdrawal from the strip, interspersed with bouts of violence between Israel and Hamas or Islamic Jihad, with civilians as the main victims
  • diminishing prospects for an independent Palestinian state.

Consequently, 2023 has seen a significant rise in violent clashes between Israelis and Palestinians, mostly in the West Bank, but also in Gaza and inside Israel.

This was the situation on the eve of Hamas’ horrendous attack on southern Israel on October 7. The savage massacres of at least 1,400 Israeli civilians, including whole families, women, children, babies and the elderly – in addition to the kidnapping of an estimated 200 more civilians – shocked the world. It brought an instantaneous Israeli declaration of war against Hamas.

The first 11 days of Israeli bombardments of the Gaza Strip have left more than 3,000 Palestinians dead – mostly civilians. Many thousands have been wounded. These numbers will continue to grow with no end in sight to the terrible carnage.

ALSO READ: Saudi plans to ‘de-risk’ region has taken a hit with Gaza violence − but hitting pause on normalisation with Israel will buy kingdom time

Little empathy across fences

Israeli historian Yuval Noah Harari has noted that while nations can become at once victims and perpetrators of violence, such situations can be psychologically difficult to cope with.

Indeed, once we choose to support a side in a conflict, we may go to great lengths to defend its actions. New information, processed through our filters and conditioned responses, can be used to challenge, or cast doubt, on any claim made by the other side. The more emotionally invested we become in the cause, the harder it is for us to empathise with the suffering experienced across the fence.

Over the past days, heated debates and protests around the world have demonstrated this “empathy deficit” in action. On one side, many supporters of the pro-Palestinian camp, exasperated by the rapid increase in casualties and deteriorating conditions in Gaza, have seemed reluctant to extend empathy to Israeli victims.

Across the divide, traumatised supporters of Israel have reacted furiously to any attempt to draw lines or parallels between the Hamas attack and Israel’s mistreatment of Palestinians.

ALSO READ: Bassem Youssef, the man who owned the internet in a single interview and rattled Piers Morgan on Gaza

Saying ‘no’ to any violence against civilians

Free Palestine supporters have often been reluctant in the past to publicly criticise Hamas. For those who live in the occupied territories, fear may have been a factor. Another possible reason could have been the belief that disparaging groups like Hamas would undermine the cohesiveness and solidarity of their camp, and thus, play into the hands of Israel.

A question for the Palestinians to ask themselves, though, is whether the campaign is inflicting greater damage on its cause, both morally and practically, by not distancing itself more categorically from violent groups, like Hamas and Islamic Jihad, who target civilians. This question seems all the more relevant in the aftermath of October 7 and the current situation in Gaza.

By provoking Israel and retreating to hide behind its own civilian population as human shields – with full knowledge of what Israel’s response would be – Hamas demonstrated a willingness to sacrifice thousands of Gazans in the hope of raising the world’s anger against Israel.

This highly immoral and cruel strategy seems to have worked only partially so far. A sharp increase in civilian casualties following an expected ground incursion by Israel, however, may lead to further shifts in international opinion.

ALSO READ: ‘Gaza is being strangled’: Why Israel’s evacuation order violates international law

Ending the occupation

Decades of Israeli occupation of the Palestinian territories, meanwhile, have inflicted immeasurable hurt and suffering on the Palestinian people. The occupation has also caused significant damage to Israel’s social fabric, cohesion, economy, international standing, security, moral stature and more. The occupation should end, and the sooner the better.

The question is how.

The challenges, already vexing before Hamas’ attack, have become immeasurably greater. Would Israelis be willing to risk having a Hamas-run Palestinian state not just in Gaza, but potentially one day in the West Bank, as well, just 10 kilometres from Tel Aviv?

Many foreign governments have been formulating their policies on the conflict with the aim of minimising potential harm to their diplomatic, geo-strategic or economic interests. The world has lost hope in the viability of proposed solutions currently on the table. Global attention is also short. As soon as one cycle of violence ends, the world’s focus will drift away from Israel-Palestine to the next crisis.

Many Western countries, including Australia, continue to profess support for the Palestinians’ right to a state, but without formally recognising such a state.

This recognition, the argument goes, should be made as part of the negotiations over a two-state solution – one for Israelis and the other for Palestinians. However, as meaningful negotiations have not been carried out for years, how helpful, really, is such a policy for advancing a resolution to the conflict?

Recognition of West Jerusalem as Israel’s capital could and should go hand-in-hand with formal recognition of a Palestinian state, with East Jerusalem as its capital.

Perhaps the concern and passion currently being manifested by supporters of the two sides could lead this time to more effective action.

Those who care about Palestine should denounce terror, cruelty and violence against civilians, and put more pressure on their governments to support an end to the Israeli occupation in return for more viable solutions for Israel’s legitimate security needs. Those who are concerned about Israel should do the same.

There are no easy solutions to the conflict, but military ones won’t do anymore. Violence only begets more violence. It has to stop.

Eyal Mayroz, Senior Lecturer in Peace and Conflict Studies, University of Sydney

*This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

A Russian media outlet turns on Google SA
The EU pork industry under pressure as tensions with main importer China increase
WATCH: Gaza refugees face dire conditions as humanitarian aid falls short
The wreck of a hero US navy submarine located
As disasters and heat intensify, can the world meet the urgency of the moment at the COP28 climate talks?
TAGGED:GazaIsraelPalestine
Share This Article
Facebook Flipboard Pinterest Whatsapp Whatsapp LinkedIn Tumblr Reddit VKontakte Telegram Threads Email Copy Link Print
What do you think?
Love0
Sad0
Happy0
Surprise0
Shy0
Joy0
Cry0
Embarrass0
Sleepy0
Angry0
Dead0
Wink0
Previous Article The story of tomatoes, everything goes global The story of tomatoes: China’s Belt and Road Initiative 10 years on
Next Article The story of rice, everything goes global. World Map with a picture of a ship on China. The story of rice: China’s Belt and Road initiative ten years later
2 Comments
  • Pingback: Israel bombards Gaza, Lebanon, Netanyahu convenes war cabinet
  • Pingback: Israel-Hamas war, children are the ultimate pawns – and victims

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Stay Connected

FacebookLike
XFollow
PinterestPin
InstagramFollow
YoutubeSubscribe
TiktokFollow
LinkedInFollow
TumblrFollow
ThreadsFollow
BlueskyFollow
RSS FeedFollow
- Advertisement -
Ad imageAd image

Latest News

Rutube: A Thriving Platform for Russian Content & Creator Monetisation
BRICS Россия (Rossiya)
New Development Bank and SANRAL Sign ZAR7 Billion Deal to Upgrade South Africa road infrastructure upgrade
BRICS South Africa
Unlocking Africa’s potential through bold collaboration and stronger investability
BRICS South Africa
What is the G20 Summit? | G20 South Africa 2025 | Brand South Africa
BRICS South Africa

You Might Also Like

BRICSBRICS PlusInternational

Taliban’s bid for BRICS: A strategic move for international recognition

July 12, 2025
Kremlin critic Boris Nadezhdin
International

Vladimir Putin challenger, Boris Nadezhdin submits presidential bid

February 1, 2024
السعودية (Al-Su'udiyya)Internationalایران (Irān)

Saudi Arabia calls for restraint after Iran launches a drone strike on Israel

April 14, 2024
MBS during BRICS summit on Gaza.
International

Gaza onslaught: What Saudi Arabia’s Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman (MBS) told BRICS leaders

November 23, 2023

Our Partners

Ad imageAd image

Learn About BRICS

  • B – Brasil
  • R – Россия (Rossiya)
  • I – भारत (Bhārat)
  • C – 中国 (Zhōngguó)
  • S – South Africa
  • Saudi Vision 2030

Our World

  • A message from the Founder & CEO
  • Support Centre
  • Careers

Google Translate

BGTNBGTN
Follow US
© 2025 BRICS Global Television Network (Pty) Ltd. All Rights Reserved. Independent Media Platform. Unauthorized ownership claims or affiliations are unlawful.
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Username or Email Address
Password

Lost your password?